Pool Heater Gas vs Electric

 Pool Heater Gas vs Electric | Which One Is better for You

The pool heater is very effective for a pool. It will help you to enhance your swimming season. If you are a pool lover and you want to spend more time in your pool then a pool heater can help you to extend your pool season. By bringing up the water temperature a few degrees lets you dive into your pool a little earlier in the spring season. These steps will help you to know the benefits of a gas vs electric pool heater.

Pool Heater Gas Vs Electric | Which One is best for me?

We have two main options for in-pool ground heaters; gas pool heater and electric heat pumps. With the rising cost of propane and natural gas and advances in electric heat pump technology, electric heat pumps become more effective.

Getting gassed up

If you have a home that is on a natural gas line, you can choose to add a gas heater. You have to use propane when your home is not in a natural gas line. It can increase your installation costs because you have to buy a propane tank. The cost depends on the rules where you live.

Pool Heater Gas vs Electric

Gas pool heater’s average cost is between $1,500 and $2,500.installation cost is additional and runs to $500 to $1,500. Generally, the gas pool heater is easy to install but difficult to operate.

Plugging it in

Many homeowners prefer the electric heat pumps because this is energy efficient and the outdoor temperature around them doesn’t fall below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. The average cost of an electric heat pump is between $2,500 and $3,500, with professional installation adding about $1,000 to the cost. Although the electric heat pump is more expensive to buy, it has less running costs than a gas unit.


There are many factors that will impact your actual pool heater costs. The size of your pool also matters if you have a pool which is large than it will cost more. A gas heater costs around $200 to $400 a month to run. An electric heat pump will cost every month from $100 to $200. So, the difference shows that, although more expensive to install but an electric heat pump could save you money in the long term.

Efficiency and installation

Typically, gas pool heaters have a greater environmental impact than electric heat pumps. Although electric heat pumps take a longer time to heat up your pool water and it is less efficient in colder temperatures. Because electric heat pumps rely on outside heat to warm up the pool water. However, by using a pool cover you can avoid these issues. the cover will help you to trap the heat in the water and make the process faster.

By setting up a natural gas pool heater, you should have to connect the unit to your gas line and propane needs a propane tank to work. but the electric heat pump needs certified technicians who can properly install the equipment. In the gas pool heater installation, we just have to connect the unit to our gas line.

Taking usage into account

Now we are comparing the costs of gas and electric pool heaters, so bear in mind that how and when you want to use your pool. a gas heater can warm pool water very quickly and you only need to run your heater when you want to go for a dip.on the other hand, the electric pool heater needs to stay all the time. If you only want to heat your pool once in a day, a gas heater will cost you less.

You may want to know the 3 types of Pool heater

Also keep that in mind, the limitations of electric pool heaters. If you are ready to keep your pool open when the temperature dips below 45 degrees Fahrenheit, you will need to opt for a gas pool heater rather than an electric heat pump regardless of cost. Remember, the temperature of your pool water also matters. the temperature depends on various types of people. Someone’s comfortable swimming temperature is 77-degree or 85 degree.it is depends on a swimmer.

Soaking up the sun

If you live in a sunny area, you can go for an electric and gas pool heater altogether. The electric heat pump uses the sun’s energy indirectly. It collects heat from the air and makes your pool warm. gas pool heater doesn’t need the sun’s energy. But it needs a propane tank that will cost much.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to heat a pool with an electric pool heater?

Generally, a heat pump usually requires between 24 and 72 hours to heat a swimming pool by 20°F (11°C). Now you know what factors will affect your swimming pool. The electric pool heater takes a long time to warm water. It takes a whole day or more than a whole day to warm water. By adding an electric heat pump you can enjoy your swim time so many times in a day.

Is it expensive to heat a pool with an electric pool heater?

Electric pool heaters installation cost is expensive but you will get less cost on a monthly basis. It will cost you $50 to $150 monthly. Electric heaters also work independently of the surrounding environment like a gas heater. This pool heater has a higher lifespan than gas. It is expensive to install and needs the proper air temperature to operate. The electric heat pump will heat the pool water slowly.

Final Thought

If you simply want to enhance your swimming season, opening it a month or two early and closing it a month or two later and closing it a month or two later, then an electric heat pump might be the way to go if you can afford the installation cost. In the winter season, you can use gas or standard resistance electric heater. Some areas have plentiful hydroelectric power and cheap electric bills and that area is best for electric heat pump installation. In other areas, it might be cheaper to use natural gas pool heater or propane. now you have everything about gas pool heater vs electric pool heater.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *